The Nose Knows (we just need to train it)

blog ExNose exhaust

 

I ride a bike for sport and fitness and so have spent countless hours on, or alongside the road.  As I have labored up narrow canyons, being passed by machines with exponentially greater horsepower than my two legs, I have become increasingly aware that not all exhaust is created equal.  Reading the New York Times recently and having experience the aroma of my own diesel vehicle, I now understand why.  Exhaust, like any other waste product is made up of constituent parts.  That chemistry has a lot to do with the greenhouse gas production of any given vehicle and, therefore, is something we all need to be concerned about.  While we could all educate ourselves reading technical manuals, Car and Driver, or consulting the EPA website, I am suggesting a simpler and more personal approach.  Your nose knows.

Cognitive psychology tells us that our sense of smell, the most ancient and animally attuned of our senses, generates the most profound feelings and memories in us.  With this in mind, I would like us all to become connoisseurs of exhaust.  Here’s why.

“This planet will not be rescued by superexpensive technology for the few, but when the majority of the mobility is clean….Diesel is far less expensive than plug is and EVs, with better range and performance.   Many models carry multigallon tanks of urea, a liquid that produces ammonia to scrub smog forming nitrogen oxides from the exhaust.”  Rainer Michel VP Product Planning VW America.

So that creates a particular odor, an exhaust signature, that we should all familiarize ourselves with.

Bio-diesel exhaust has a unique aroma as well, a sometimes sulfurous, sometimes fast-food hint, that may or may not become associated with the smell of progress.  Here is why

“Biodiesel exhaust is less offensive. The use of biodiesel and biodiesel blends results in a noticeable, less offensive change in exhaust odor.  The use of biodiesel in a conventional diesel engine results in substantial reduction of unburned hydrocarbons, carbon monoxide, and particulate matter. Emissions of nitrogen oxides are either slightly reduced or slightly increased depending on the duty cycle and testing methods. The use of biodiesel decreases the solid carbon fraction of particulate matter (since the oxygen in biodiesel enables more complete combustion to CO2), eliminates the sulfate fraction (as there is no sulfur in the fuel), while the soluble, or hydrocarbon, fraction stays the same or is increased.” Biodiesel.org

Here again, if we attune our sensibilities to what smells right we can quickly develop a common sense approach to combustion and establish a criteria that is easily intuited and universal.

The Internal combustion engine, by contrast, produces emissions that are dangerous, toxic, potentially fatal, and large contributors to the accumulation of greenhouse gas.

“Not all of the fuel is completely consumed by the combustion process; a small amount of fuel is present after combustion, and some of it reacts to form oxygenates, such as formaldehyde or acetaldehyde, or hydrocarbons not originally present in the input fuel mixture. The flame is “quenched” by the relatively cool cylinder walls, leaving behind unreacted fuel that is expelled with the exhaust.” Wikipedia

These trace elements have their own odor footprint, an aroma that is familiar to all of us as it is ubiquitous throughout the world.

But is this the smell that comforts?  I recall pumping gas as a kid and genuinely enjoying the fumes that escaped from the tank during the fill up.  I think we can all relate to the exhaust of a two stroke lawn mower engine combined with the smell of freshly cut grass as one of the happy memories of summer.  Perhaps it is time for a new sensibility, a new set of smells and a new normal.  Our sense of smell has powerful and personal psychological effects it can be harnessed to work for the greater good.

Mechanix Illustrated (Nov, 1938) Device Makes Automobile Exhaust Gases Harmless

 

 

A- Blue smoke indicates oil B- Dark Gray indicated the fuel is too rich and C-White indicates a leaking gasket, usually coolant

Fly Ash in Concrete

R FlyAsh NeonTumbler

There has been a lot of discussion recently about fly ash in concrete as there are concerns about heavy metals in this by-product of coal fired power production.

 “Replacing Portland cement is a high priority for all of us…” Russell Perry, Smith Group

“The Environmental Building News (Alex Wilson) continues to support the use of coal fly ash in building materials as long as:

  1. the use of fly ash reduces green house gas emissions elsewhere in the materials stream and
  2. the fly ash is chemically and physically locked up so that the risk of leaching is kept acceptably low.

A 2008 study by researchers at The Ohio State University found that fly ash concrete exposed to heat through steam curing retained 99% of its mercury content and showed final emissions similar to thoseof common soil.

A follow up study at Ohio State in 2009 that looked at both gas emissions and liquid leaching showed that the amount of mercury emitted from fly ash concrete was independent of the amount of mercury in the cement.

In California and much of the Western United States, the primary cement substitute in concrete is slag. Bode concrete, for example, advertises a “green” mix that is 30% slag and 15% flay ash, in place of 45% of Portland Cement.

R-FlyAsh-Pumper
Concrete Pumper laying a slab

Slag is byproduct of the metal smelting process. Common components of slag include the oxides of silicon, aluminum, and magnesium, as well as sulfur, which is always present. Slag also contains phosphorous, calcium, ash, remnants of flux materials such as limestone, and remainders of chemical reactions between the metal and the furnace lining. Slag cement has actually been used in concrete projects in the United States for over a century. The earliest use of slag cement was documented in 1774, when it was combined with slaked lime and used as a mortar. Slag cement was first used commercially in Germany in the 1860s, and it was such a success that engineers in 1889 decided to build the Paris underground metro using slag-lime cement.

R-FlyAsh-Breaker

Eco-Justice

R EcoJ EBBoatScrap

Supporters of eco-justice attack the historic lack of regard for non-human parts of the environment. They encourage respect for living things as well as the various parts of the biosphere.

Advocates of eco-justice reject the idea that the worth of a thing is its value to human beings. They argue that other parts of nature have value entirely independent of their usefulness to humanity.

R-EcoJ-EBScrapGreen
Edward Burtynsky – Manufactured Landscapes

Natural systems depend on diversity, and adaptation to provide resilience in a dynamic environment

Human beings, as part of this system, depend upon bio-diversity as a reservoir of potential that allows for the entire system to respond to changing conditions.

R-EcoJ-EBOrangeFlow
Edward Burtynsky – Manufactured Landscapes

Given our growing ability to comprehend the profound nature of these inter-relationships, human beings have an ethical responsibility to protect these processes.

Wasteful practices and their hazardous byproducts have typically impacted the less fortunate (or less vocal), be they human, animal or plant, giving rise to the idea of Eco-Justice

R-EcoJ-EBMarket
Edward Burtynsky – Manufactured Landscapes

There are a variety of Guidelines and programs aimed at reducing our environmental footprint.  The more modest attempt to be “less bad.” The most progressive propose to create a healing framework.

  • Reducing Impacts
  • Increasing efficiency
  • Achieving Net Zero Energy Use
  • Achieving Net Zero Water Use
  • Building Regenerative Systems
R-EcoJ-EBOilFields
Edward Burtynsky – Oil

Architect’s Response

R-EcoJ-LogoBIG R-EcoJ-LogoUSGBC R-EcoJ-LogoPHA R-EcoJ-LogoLBC R-EcoJ-LogoISO